The Credit Suisse AT1 Bond Controversy Revisited

Where the Dispute Stands and What Comes Next

On 19 March 2023, the Swiss Financial Market Supervisory Authority (FINMA) ordered Credit Suisse to write down its Additional Tier 1 (AT1) notes to zero. The notes had a nominal value of about CHF 16 billion. More than three years later, a Swiss court has annulled that order. The appeal is before the Federal Supreme Court, and the notes remain written down.
This article is a companion to our briefing of May 2023. It sets out what has been decided, what that means for the argument we made then, and what is still to come.
The Position in May 2023
Our earlier briefing made three points:
Design: AT1 is going-concern capital. A write-down ahead of shareholders is what the instrument is designed for, and seniority in a liquidation does not prevent a write-down.
Disclosure: The terms and risk factors of the Credit Suisse notes said that a write-down could occur while the shares remained outstanding. Professional investors had no legitimate expectation of equal treatment with shareholders.
Open Questions: Two questions were for the Swiss courts to decide: whether the Viability Event had occurred, and whether the emergency ordinance was a valid basis for the order.
Like FINMA and several commentators at the time, we expected the challenge to fail on the terms. The first court to rule has decided otherwise.
Key Dates
DATE | EVENT |
19 March 2023 | FINMA orders the write-down. Hours earlier, Credit Suisse had told FINMA that it did not consider the contractual conditions met. |
12 June 2023 | UBS completes the merger and takes the place of Credit Suisse in the proceedings. |
1 October 2025 | The Federal Administrative Court annuls the order in a lead case. The decision is sent to the parties on 14 October. |
October and November 2025 | FINMA and UBS appeal to the Federal Supreme Court. The other AT1 cases are suspended. |
December 2025 | The Supreme Court grants suspensive effect, so the notes remain written down. Japanese investors file treaty arbitration claims against Switzerland. |
March 2026 | The Supreme Court declines to invite the Federal Department of Finance to take part. |
19 March 2026 | Three years have passed since the write-down. Holders had been advised to interrupt limitation periods by this date. |
July 2026 | A United States appeals court confirms that Switzerland is immune from a bondholder claim brought in New York. |
16 September 2026 | In a separate case, the Supreme Court upholds the cancellation of Credit Suisse bonuses and reverses the Federal Administrative Court. |
20 November 2026 | No decision on the AT1 appeals has yet been published. |
The Decision of 1 October 2025
The Federal Administrative Court ruled in a lead case brought by three holders of the 4.500% notes issued in 2020. About 360 further proceedings, with about 3,000 complainants, are suspended until the decision is final. The court annulled FINMA's order. Its reasoning has three parts:
Terms of the Notes: No Viability Event had occurred. The public support limb requires support that improves the capital adequacy of Credit Suisse. The liquidity facilities provided liquidity, and Credit Suisse met its capital requirements. The federal loss guarantee went to UBS. The other limb also failed, because FINMA gave no notice and a Tier 2 instrument was left untouched.
Banking Legislation: Protective measures (Banking Act, Article 26) are provisional and may affect creditors only indirectly. They do not allow FINMA to extinguish claims. Nor does the general supervisory power (Financial Market Supervision Act, Article 31).
Emergency Ordinance: The provision that let FINMA order the write-down set no conditions and gave no guidance. Parliament had already legislated for the failure of a systemically important bank, so emergency law could not displace that regime. The provision also left the decision to FINMA, which the Swiss Constitution does not permit.
The court gave weight to Credit Suisse's own reading of the terms. Hours before the order, the bank wrote to FINMA that the measures concerned liquidity and not capital. It added that a write-down would be "a gift of ca CHF 16bn to the shareholders of the acquiring party".
The court classified the write-down as a formal expropriation, for which the Constitution requires full compensation. None had been provided for. The court did not decide the remedy. The request to reverse the write-down is still pending before it.
What Held and What Did Not
ISSUE | OUR 2023 VIEW | OUTCOME FIRST INSTANCE |
Write-Down Ahead of Shareholders | This is by design. Seniority in a liquidation does not prevent it. | Not struck down. The court accepted that a write-down within the terms would not have interfered with the holders' rights. |
Investor Expectations | No legitimate expectation of equal treatment with shareholders. | Not the ground of decision. The holders won on the wording of the trigger. |
Viability Event | Left for the courts to decide. We expected the holders to fail. | Decided for the holders. Neither limb was met. |
Emergency Ordinance | Left for the courts to decide. | Held unconstitutional. |
EU and UK Practice | No guide to the Swiss notes. | Played no part. The case turned on Swiss contract and constitutional law. |
The decision does not say that AT1 holders rank equally with shareholders. It says that a regulator may trigger a write-down only on the conditions the notes state, or on a clear statutory basis. Our 2023 briefing asked investors to read the terms. The court has held the regulator to the same terms.
Where the Proceedings Stand
Appeal: FINMA and UBS have appealed to the Federal Supreme Court. In December 2025 the court gave the UBS appeal suspensive effect, so the notes remain written down until it rules. A decision had been expected in summer 2026. None had been published when this article was finished.
Suspended Cases: The other proceedings before the Federal Administrative Court are suspended until the lead decision is final.
Other Claims in Switzerland: Advisers warned holders to interrupt limitation periods before 19 March 2026 in order to preserve other claims, including possible claims against UBS. UBS said in October 2025 that it expected no liability and had made no provision.
Treaty Arbitration: Japanese investors filed requests for arbitration against Switzerland at the International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID) in December 2025. Switzerland has received further notices of dispute. No ruling on jurisdiction or liability has been reported.
United States: A claim for USD 370M against Switzerland in New York was dismissed in 2025. An appeals court confirmed the dismissal in July 2026, because Switzerland had acted as a sovereign and is immune from suit.
What the Federal Supreme Court Has to Decide
The appeals are not public. On the reasoning of the lower court, four questions arise:
Standing: Whether bondholders may challenge an order that was addressed to the bank.
Trigger: The lower court read the Viability Event as the parties to the notes did and gave no weight to the regulatory rule behind it. Critics answer that liquidity and capital cannot be separated in a bank run. Two professors at the University of Bern argue that the public support limb does not require a breach of capital requirements.
Statutory Basis: Whether FINMA's powers over a bank in danger of insolvency extend to an order of this kind.
Emergency Ordinance: Whether the Federal Council could use emergency law where the too-big-to-fail regime already applied, and whether it could leave the decision to FINMA.
A recent ruling gives a limited signal. On 16 September 2026 the Supreme Court reversed the same lower court in the Credit Suisse bonus case. It found that the Banking Act (Article 10a) allowed the cancellation of variable pay at a bank that had received state aid. That case concerned an express statutory power. The AT1 case concerns a contractual trigger and an emergency ordinance. The ruling shows that the court will uphold a crisis measure that has a clear statutory basis. It does not decide the AT1 question.
Three outcomes are possible:

Only the first route leads to a decision on reinstatement or compensation.
Appeals Dismissed: The annulment becomes final and the suspended cases resume. The Federal Administrative Court then decides the remedy. The holders ask for the write-down to be reversed. The court has also named the Confederation as the expropriating party, which suggests compensation by the state. Either result can be appealed again.
Appeals Upheld: FINMA's order stands and the challenge to it ends. The treaty arbitrations would continue on their own legal basis, but with less support from the Swiss courts.
Case Sent Back: The Supreme Court may return the case to the lower court for further findings. The lower court decided without a further exchange of submissions. UBS has said that it appealed so that its view of the facts is taken into account.
On any of these outcomes, a final answer on who pays, and how much, is years away.
What Has Changed in the Rules
Switzerland
Trigger: A new Article 27a of the Capital Adequacy Ordinance has applied since 1 January 2025. When the trigger occurs, FINMA orders the write-down or conversion and fixes its timing and amount. The Federal Administrative Court noted that the revised rule is worded more precisely.
Design of AT1: In 2025 the Federal Council proposed to strengthen the role of AT1 in absorbing losses while a bank is a going concern. It also examined abolishing the instrument. On 22 April 2026 it shelved the proposed changes for the time being, because the international discussion on AT1 is still open.
Capital Debate: The Banking Act bill would require systemically important banks to back their foreign subsidiaries in full with Common Equity Tier 1 (CET1) capital. A compromise would have allowed up to half of that backing in specially designed AT1. The Council of States rejected the compromise on 23 September 2026 and voted for 90% CET1. The National Council takes up the bill in the winter session.
Other Jurisdictions
Australia: The prudential regulator (APRA) is removing AT1 from its capital framework for banks from 1 January 2027. Existing instruments count as Tier 2 until their first call date and are expected to be gone by 2032.
European Union: In December 2025 the European Central Bank (ECB) set out two options: strengthen the features of AT1, or remove it from going-concern capital. The European Banking Authority (EBA) assessed the second option in June 2026. It found that removal would leave 56 institutions short of CET1 and could disrupt a mature market.
India: On 15 October 2026 the Supreme Court upheld a judgment quashing the 2020 write-off of INR 8,415 crore of Yes Bank AT1 bonds. It held that the bank's administrator had no power to order it. Yes Bank and the Reserve Bank of India have applied for a review.
Two themes run through these international developments. Regulators seem to doubt that AT1 does its job while a bank is still a going concern. And courts will not uphold a write-down that lacks a clear legal basis.
Points for Issuers and Investors
Read the Trigger: AT1 notes are not alike. The Credit Suisse dispute turned on a few words about capital adequacy in one limb of one definition.
The Terms Bind the Regulator: A regulator that approves the terms of an instrument is held to them when it later intervenes, unless statute gives it a separate power.
Contract or Statute: Switzerland chose a contractual trigger for the point of non-viability. In the EU, including Denmark, the power to write down or convert capital instruments at that point is statutory (BRRD, Articles 59 and 60). The order of losses is fixed by law. A dispute about the wording of a viability clause is less likely there. A dispute about whether the statutory conditions were met remains possible.
Danish Issuers: Danish AT1 terms follow the Capital Requirements Regulation, with a CET1 trigger of at least 5.125%. A write-down or conversion on that trigger can still occur while the shares remain outstanding. Risk factors should say so plainly, as the Credit Suisse documents did.
Credit Suisse Noteholders: Some holders filed complaints in 2023 or interrupted limitation periods before 19 March 2026. They are in a stronger position than those who did neither. Any holder should take advice on what remains open.
Asset Class: Australia is removing AT1 and the EU is reviewing it. Issuers should expect the design of new instruments to change.
In May 2023 we wrote that whether the conditions of the write-down were met was a question for the Swiss courts. One court of first instance has now answered it. The Federal Supreme Court will have the last word.
This briefing is intended to provide general information on finance and capital markets topics. It is not intended to provide definitive legal or tax advice. No legal, tax or business decisions should be based solely on its content. The briefing does not necessarily deal with every important topic and is not designed to provide legal or other advice. It shall not be used as a substitute for legal advice and none may be inferred. It is only intended for general information on matters of interest. While we endeavour to represent the information as accurately and correctly as possible, we cannot accept any responsibility for any errors or omissions.
_JPG.jpg)


